By Gari Voss
News published on May 1, 2025, by several news outlets stated that the Allegan Public Schools would not permit students to sing songs from Christian artists Colton Dixon and Brandon Lake at the audition for their school talent show because of the religious content.
The First Liberty Institute, a liberty law firm, received the information and jumped on the claim which was referred to as “inexcusable discrimination” in a statement that came to the attention of the press.
Superintendent Antoine explained that neither the staff nor parents at West Ward Elementary had consulted his office for clarification regarding the district’s position on the singing of religious themed music. Thus began the misunderstanding and the sharp response from Kayla Toney, the counsel for the First Liberty Institute, who had not called Mr. Antoine to qualify the situation before sending out press releases.
Those who have had students in the Allegan schools over the years know that often there is religious themed music performed during concerts and talent shows, in music classes, and in competitions. The wonderful melodies and harmonies assist in building young voices and expanding the students’ repertoire of music.
When Supt. Antoine learned of the misstep by the West Ward staff, he immediately responded to the school staff and the media.
“This morning, it was brought to the attention of Allegan Public Schools that concerns had been raised about the handling of student auditions for the upcoming talent show at West Ward Elementary. Specifically, the concern involved whether students were being prohibited from performing a song that contains religious lyrics, and that the family was asked to consider choosing an alternate song.
“Upon review, it was determined that school staff were unfamiliar with the legal guidelines concerning religious expression in a public school setting.
“To clarify: students are permitted to perform songs of their choice, including those with religious content, provided the material complies with the student code of conduct – particularly regarding language and theme.
“Religious songs have been, and will continue to be, allowed at school events like talent shows. We are pleased to report that this matter was resolved quickly. The student was given the opportunity to audition and will be performing in the upcoming talent show.
“We are also reviewing our internal communication processes to ensure that similar matters are appropriately reviewed before decisions are communicated to students or families. We regret any confusion or frustration this situation may have caused and remain committed to supporting our students’ diverse talents.”
It is not known if school staff will review the Respect Project training program, www.respectproject.net, as requested by First Liberty to ensure that students of all faiths are free to express their beliefs in accordance with the protections of the First Amendment, but staff members across the district now know the importance of asking more questions before making statements about protocol and school policy to students, parents and/or the public.
